Skip to main content

Sport vs Self-defense

There are topics in BJJ that repeats themselves on online forums.

One of them is sport vs self defense.

It seems that they are 2 gangs in Jiu-Jitsu: the sport gang and the self-defense gang.

As any good stories, rivalry is compulsary for the existence of gang.

After all if you do not have a rival for your gang, there is no need for the existence of your gang.

Since, no one seems to get along in the BJJ community: teams vs teams, art vs art, gi vs nogi, club vs gyms, loyalty vs traitors (creonte) etc.

It seems totally normal to add sport vs self-defense to the list of what makes BJJ such a great martial art...

Opps, such a great sport.

So where do we stand?

Pretty much in the middle I must say.
I could not care less about sport BJJ.
Yeah, it is great to be able to use your skills in a competitive environment.
But the rules and point system are complicated, the competitions are expensive and too long. Not many students actually competes to make it worth it.
It seems maybe 10-20 % of students would compete and even if it the case, it just simply does not pay for the bills.


So what do you do as an instructor? Just concentrate on the minority of your students needs and ignore the needs and interest of the majority of your paying customers.

Sport BJJ is just no longer realistic.
They do not even train for takedown in most gyms, they just pull train guard!



While on the other hand, we have the self defense gang.

They no longer really interested in sport competition.
They teach takedowns, striking , they spar with gloves, teach the ibjjf illegal techniques. 
Nothing wrong with that. 
I would say that most people join bjj to learn how to defend themselves on the streets and no one really enters a bjj gym in hope to become a bjj champion.
If you watch some old instructional video of Renzo Gracie and Kukuk, he teaches BJJ and explains how to use it against strikes.
When was the last time you watch a video of BJJ with the same style and topic?
Never! Everything is about scoring points etc..
Are we making a comeback to self-defense?
Is there no market for dvd for self-defense?
Is it just me or only sport bjj guys are suckers for buying every sport bjj dvd or seminars?
 
However, Some of them are guilty of just happily clipping the ticket.
They just cash in and train people because BJJ is now a popular sport created on the back of others fighting to prove its worthiness.

It seems that you are now forced into choosing side.

Choose carefully!

Just kidding, just find a club that offers what you are interested into.

Or just find a smart instructor that caters for both.


Oh well, let's not get along because as usual martial arts should make you a better person.

Oops, sport should make you a better person.






Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What is this tab on your Jiu Jitsu belt?

As we are getting closer to graduation, students that are not getting promoted to the next belt will likely to receive stripes instead. If you do not have a black tab on your belt, we cannot give you stripes. Why do we have stripes? The Gracies decided to have a stripes system in order to be different from Judo. As it takes 1-3 years between belts, it is nice to receive stripes once in a while. How often do we give stripes? It is usually done during graduation which is usually held twice a year (August and December). What if you miss the graduation event? No worries, we will give them during the following classes.   How many stripes can I get? You can get up to 4 stripes. Is there a minimum number of stripes in order to get the next belt?   No, in fact some schools do not bother with stripes. You can move to the next belt even if you do not have any stripes. What is the red tab for? It is for the instructors. A blue

The curse of the blue belt

I will teach you a black belt magic trick in Jiu Jitsu. If you want a student to disappear: give him a blue belt. It is recurring event in the life of an instructor and a club. If you think the drop out of white belts is bad enough, the ratio of drop out of the blue belts is worst. I am not sure if I agree with statistics on this picture. But the issue is not really about arguing about the percentages of drop out but more on discussing the reasons for such drop out and what we can do to prevent it.  Reasons for the drop out: It takes a long time to achieve a blue belt. It average between 1-3 years. After 1-3 years of training, people loose interest and wants to start a new sport or hobby. The goal of the student was to achieve the blue belt and not the black belt. Personal situations changes over the years. Lot of people that start training are young single males with disposable income. Lot of them are at university level or are single. Add a few more years and they

Auckland BJJ Police Training

  On the 17th of January we had our second Police training session at Auckland BJJ. Several of our members are police officers and they had asked if they can use the Dojo to do some training and practice off duty. We were happy to help and Stu and Jora helped out organizing the training.  We covered a few techniques that we thought would help these officers, and then we did some sparing sessions where they could apply these techniques. Below is a video of one of our arrest the black belt sessions :-) Auckland BJJ is happy to help the NZ police. Here is a gratuitous shot of my daughter and a police car.